Steve's Book Stuff
Posts
Double Book Review: A Wrinkle in Time & A Wind in the Door

Double Book Review: A Wrinkle in Time & A Wind in the Door

November 01, 2021

The first of what became a series of interrelated books, A Wrinkle in Time was considered unprintable when it made the rounds at publishing houses in 1960. A mix of science fiction and fantasy, fable and parable, the religious and the irreligious, it was considered too much for younger audiences and too odd for adult audiences. Finally picked up and published in 1962 by Farrar, Strauss and Cudahy it has defied the opinions of those early editors, and remained in print ever since.

A Wrinkle in Time won the 1963 Newbery Medal. It was adapted into a well received made-for-TV movie in 2003, and a less well received theatrical one in 2018. It has also been adapted as a play and as a graphic novel. It has been cited by the American Library Association as one of the most commonly challenged (i.e. banned) books in the United States both for its religious themes and it’s “supernatural” content. It is today considered a classic young adult book.

It’s also a book that, sadly, I had never read until now. For whatever reason the book has existed just on the edge of my awareness and interest. But casting about recently for something more fantasy and less hard science fiction I picked it up.

I will also admit that I was influenced by reading this recent article from Mental Floss about the origin of the phrase “It was a dark and stormy night” as a metaphor for bad writing. The author notes that the line “was a well-known trope in 1962, when Madeleine L’Engle co-opted it as the opening line of her classic fantasy novel”. Well, I thought, that took courage as a writer, so I had to find out more…

This is the story of Meg Murry, her younger brother Charles Wallace, and their new friend Calvin O’Keefe, all three of whom are pulled into an adventure in search of their missing father. Led by Mrs. Whatsit, Mrs. Which and Mrs. Who they encounter memorable characters like the Happy Medium, Aunt Beast and the dreadful IT. It is an adventure through time and space and a battle between the epic forces of good and evil.

There isn’t a lot in the story to pin it to a specific decade or time (although when Calvin talks early on in the book a few old fashioned phrases pop out of his mouth). Much of the story seems not to have aged at all, and is as accessible today as it would have been in 1962. But that’s not to say that it’s an easily accessible book. It has always been known as a story that refuses to talk down to its younger audience, and challenges them with its references to higher level concepts of math and science.

I listened to the audiobook that included both a forward by L’Engle and an Afterward by her granddaughter. The narration was by actress Hope Davis, who did a great job voicing all the characters. So what did I think of my long delayed introduction to the book? It rates Four Stars from me. If you’ve never had a chance to pick up this book before, or even if it’s been ages since you have it’s well worth your time.

Borrow this book: Find out if your library has the ebook or audiobook available.

Support Indie Bookstores: Buy this book directly from Bookshop.org or find an Independent Bookstore near you.

A Wind in the Door by Madeleine L’Engle

Finding that I liked the first book in the series, I decided to pick up the second. A Wind in the Door picks up some time after the completion of the first book and starts with the precocious young Charles Wallace reporting to his older sister that there are dragons in their twin brother’s vegetable garden.

This second book is filled with the same mix of fantasy and science, fable, and religious references as the first. But it is a darker tale than the first book, and as such, is not really as suitable for a younger audience as its predecessor. Charles Wallace is ill, and in fact as the story develops it becomes clearer that his life is in real danger. It falls to Meg, Calvin, and the unlikeable principal of their grade school Mr Jenkins, to work through another adventurous battle between good and evil so that they can not only save poor Charles Wallace but also right the balance of the universe.

This adventure is structured as a series of lessons as laid out in an education from an unlikely creature who it turns out isn’t a dragon but rather a cherubim. Yes, there are lessons to be learned and they can only be learned through journeying deep into Charles Wallace’s cells to turn back the evil Echthros that threaten his life.

If the world and the epic journey of A Wrinkle in Time seem timeless and the main parable of the story broadly applicable, the same can’t be said for A Wind in the Door. The references to the work of the Murry children’s father seem to tie the story to the 1970s, and in fact the book was published in 1973. And the theme of the book – the cosmic struggle between good and evil – is tied to the acts of naming and counting, to allow things to be, just as God is said to have numbered every hair on our heads, and to be aware of the fate of even the lowly sparrows. Thus the book is more closely tied to a Christian understanding, and L’Engle’s own religious beliefs, than was the first book.

Perhaps it’s because of that that this story comes across as a bit too preachy to me. Also, structuring the story as a set of lessons didn’t really seem to spring out of the story itself but rather seemed a writerly crutch. Altogether I wasn’t as taken with this book as I was with A Wrinkle in Time. So for that reason I give A Wind in the Door Three Stars .

Borrow this book: Find out if your library has the ebook or audiobook available.

Support Indie Bookstores: Buy this book directly from Bookshop.org or find an Independent Bookstore near you.

Reply

or to participate.